Objective 1.3High Priority9 min read

Impact Analysis and Testing

The process of evaluating potential effects of changes on security and operations before implementation. Includes conducting impact analysis, testing in non-production environments, reviewing test results, and validating that changes work as intended.

Understanding Impact Analysis and Testing

Impact analysis and testing are the "look before you leap" phase of change management. Before implementing any change in production, you must understand what might break and verify the change actually works.

Impact analysis answers: "What could this change affect?" It identifies dependencies, potential failures, and security implications before you touch production systems.

Testing answers: "Does this change work correctly?" It validates functionality in a controlled environment where failures won't impact real users or operations.

Together, these activities prevent the most common cause of change-related incidents: unexpected consequences that weren't discovered until production.

Why This Matters for the Exam

SY0-701 emphasizes impact analysis as a critical step that's often skipped under time pressure. Exam questions frequently present scenarios where changes failed because testing was inadequate or impact wasn't properly assessed.

Understanding testing environments and methodologies helps with broader security questions. The same concepts apply to vulnerability testing, penetration testing, and security validation—all require controlled environments and systematic approaches.

Skipping impact analysis and testing is a leading cause of security incidents. A "quick" firewall change can open attack vectors. An "easy" patch can break security tools. These concepts help you understand why careful evaluation matters.

Deep Dive

Impact Analysis

Impact analysis systematically identifies what a change might affect.

Key Questions:

  • •What systems depend on the component being changed?
  • •What services will be affected?
  • •Who uses those services?
  • •What security controls might be impacted?
  • •What could fail, and what's the consequence?

Types of Impact:

Impact TypeDescriptionExample
TechnicalSystem and service effectsApplication breaks after database change
SecuritySecurity posture effectsFirewall change exposes new ports
BusinessOperational effectsOutage during peak sales period
ComplianceRegulatory effectsChange violates data handling requirements
UserEnd-user effectsLogin process changes confuse users

Impact Analysis Components:

Dependency Mapping

  • •What systems connect to this component?
  • •What data flows through it?
  • •What would break if it failed?

Risk Assessment

  • •Likelihood of negative outcomes
  • •Severity of potential impacts
  • •Risk mitigation measures

Security Review

  • •Does this change alter the attack surface?
  • •Are security controls affected?
  • •Does it introduce new vulnerabilities?

Testing Environments

Development Environment

  • •Where code is written and initially tested
  • •May not match production configuration
  • •Used for feature development

Test/QA Environment

  • •Dedicated testing environment
  • •Should mirror production closely
  • •Used for quality assurance testing

Staging Environment

  • •Near-identical to production
  • •Final validation before deployment
  • •Includes realistic data and configurations

Production Environment

  • •Live systems serving real users
  • •Changes only after testing elsewhere
  • •Highest risk for failures

Testing Progression:

  • •Development → Test/QA → Staging → Production

Types of Testing

Functional Testing

  • •Does the change do what it's supposed to?
  • •Test the intended new functionality
  • •Verify the change achieves its objective

Regression Testing

  • •Did the change break anything else?
  • •Test existing functionality still works
  • •Catch unintended side effects

Security Testing

  • •Did the change introduce vulnerabilities?
  • •Verify security controls still function
  • •Test authentication, authorization, encryption

Performance Testing

  • •How does the change affect system performance?
  • •Test under realistic load conditions
  • •Identify bottlenecks or degradation

User Acceptance Testing (UAT)

  • •Do end users approve the change?
  • •Business stakeholders validate functionality
  • •Final sign-off before production

Test Results Review

Before approving for production: • All test cases passed? • Any unexpected behaviors observed? • Security testing completed? • Performance acceptable? • Stakeholders signed off?

Validation After Implementation

Even after successful testing, validate in production: • Change achieved intended outcome • No unexpected side effects • Security controls functioning • Performance within acceptable range • Users can work normally

How CompTIA Tests This

Example Analysis

Scenario: An organization plans to upgrade their web application framework. The security team raises concerns about the change.

Impact Analysis Should Identify: • All applications using the framework • Authentication mechanisms that might be affected • Third-party integrations that depend on framework features • Security features provided by the old framework • Compliance implications (especially for apps handling sensitive data)

Testing Should Include: • Functional tests of all applications on new framework • Security testing for authentication and authorization • Regression tests to ensure existing features work • Performance testing under load • Penetration testing on the staging environment

Key insight: The framework is foundational—many things depend on it. Impact analysis should cast a wide net, and testing should be thorough. A framework upgrade isn't "just an update"; it's a high-impact change requiring comprehensive evaluation.

Key Terms to Know

impact analysischange testingtest environmentvalidationrisk assessmentregression testingstaging environment

Common Mistakes to Avoid

Testing only the changed component—regression testing must verify that UNCHANGED parts still work. Changes often break things they shouldn't touch.
Using production for testing—production testing puts real users at risk. Test environments exist specifically to catch problems before production.
Skipping security testing—functional testing shows the change works, but security testing ensures it doesn't introduce vulnerabilities.
Assuming test environment results match production—staging environments must closely mirror production. Differences in configuration, data, or scale can cause test results to be misleading.

Exam Tips

Impact analysis = Understanding what COULD be affected. Testing = Verifying things actually WORK correctly.
Regression testing is critical—it catches unintended side effects on existing functionality.
Testing environments should progress toward production: Dev → Test → Staging → Production.
Security testing should be part of every change, not just "security changes."
Validation happens AFTER deployment to confirm the change works in actual production conditions.

Memory Trick

"FIRST" for Impact Analysis

  • •Functions affected (what does it touch?)
  • •Integrations (what connects to it?)
  • •Risk level (what could go wrong?)
  • •Security implications (does it weaken security?)
  • •Timing impact (when should this happen?)

Testing Environment Progression: "DTSP" — Development → Test → Staging → Production (Don't Test in Staging or Production... wait, test in staging but not production!)

  • •Testing Types Memory:
  • •Functional = Does it work as intended?
  • •Regression = Did it break other things?
  • •Security = Did it create vulnerabilities?
  • •Performance = Is it fast enough?
  • •UAT = Do users approve?

FRSPU = "First Review Security, Performance, Users"

Test Your Knowledge

Q1.A developer tests a new feature in the development environment and it works correctly. Before deploying to production, what additional testing is MOST important?

Q2.What is the PRIMARY purpose of impact analysis before implementing a change?

Q3.During testing, a security scan reveals the change introduces a new vulnerability. What should happen?

Want more practice with instant AI feedback?

Practice with AI

Continue Learning

Change Approval ProcessBackout Plans and Maintenance WindowsTechnical Change Implications

Ready to test your knowledge?

Practice questions on impact analysis and testing and other Objective 1.3 concepts.

Start Practice
Change Approval ProcessBackout Plans and Maintenance Windows